Reshoring seems simple: bring manufacturing back home. The counterargument—offshoring saves money—is also simple, and for decades has been perceived as a winner. Reality lies somewhere in between, as the total cost of ownership needs to be considered, including intangibles.
Conceding for the moment that there is real cost savings from low–cost offshore labor, let’s look at the other factors that influence the total cost of ownership.
- Parts and materials—the cost for most products are driven much more by the cost of the bill of materials than the cost of labor. To first order, this is independent of assembly location, but second order effects are common (e.g. sub supply chains, where do the materials and labor for the parts come from?)
- Freight—both inbound, for parts and materials, and outbound, to the customer
- This includes the actual transport costs, but also packing, labor at both ends to pack and unpack, overhead for managing, shipping materials, insurance, everything
- And it really depends on mode—surface, sea or air—with the latter being a wildcard that can show up unplanned to deal with intangibles like demand shifts or expedites (see below)
- Tariffs—much has been made about this recently, so we won’t dive too deep into this, but remember this can apply at every level of the supply chain
- Automation—this is the great equalizer for labor costs, but has a significant ROI aspect that has to be addressed in cost of ownership
- Yield, scrap, and other attrition—this is related to quality, which can vary by region, but also ties to the supply chain and even automation (oftentimes the true benefit of automation isn’t labor cost reductions rather consistency and tolerances)
- Overhead—especially for lower volume products, this can be the real difference-maker in terms of reshoring vs offshoring. How many people on how many airplanes to set up and manage an offshore supply chain can swamp piece part savings
Intangibles are also important, although tougher to quantify
- Patriotism—this is the moose in the room for any discussion of reshoring, the kneejerk reaction of “build it here, in my country/state/ town.” This of course has local merit, but can lead to emotional rather than logical decisions. This isn’t the forum for that aspect, enough said.
- Branding—related to patriotism, but more tangible. Does Made in USA (or for that matter Made in Germany) add value to a brand? Not our area of expertise, but valid.
- Supply chain—this seems a duplicate from above, but supply chains are called chains for a reason, and how those chains splay out around the globe matters
- In general, the shorter the supply chain the better—a molder on the same campus as the resin compounder (their supplier) and the contract manufacturer (their customer) has a huge advantage over a supply chain where all three are on different continents
- Cost of money—there is a real cost to carrying inventory, whether on the water or in warehouses or in WIP on an assembly line.
- Agility—the shorter the overall supply chain, the easier it is for a company to be agile, change product mix based on demand shifts, new markets opening, or competition. This is often the strongest argument for reshoring, as a short, domestic supply chain can dramatically improve agility
- Management focus—if your CEO is spending all her time on midnight conference calls with a recalcitrant Asian supplier, is that really why she makes the big bucks?
- IP risk is obvious and real
- Global risks are on people’s minds at the moment, and of course it’s not just pandemics, it can be politics, war, famine, labor unrest or whatever
- Other risks include boring things like getting products through customs (has anyone not had issues at the Port of Long Beach?) or shipping damage
- Yes, insurance can cover some risk, but at a cost, and doesn’t cover intangibles like brand damage
While every product and situation are different, in general a total cost of ownership can (and should!) be modeled. This needs to include ROI, risk, cost of money, and intangibles. Then various solutions can be compared and the tradeoffs weighed in order to allow a data-driven decision. Zebulon Solutions can help both with the modeling of the various options as well as managing the actual transitions to on the planet you choose to manufacture.Read More